Color match for SuperDeck stain

I have a cedar deck stained with Canyon Brown Superdeck transparent stain. I've been underwhelmed with its performance, and I hate working with oil-based products. Its being discontinued is a perfect excuse to transition to a water-based stain. I plan to strip the deck, of course, but I like the color just fine and would like to get a stain that's close. Online ordering makes that a little tricky (I'm in AK, which means Amazon is the only potential option, can't get samples directly from the manufacturers). Defy Extreme Butternut and Light Walnut look like candidates, as do #1Deck Dark and Light Walnut. Anyone have experience with any of these and can recommend a close match? Thanks!